NHL Trade Rumors Member Posts


carnyslop's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

No Profile Picture uploaded


Where from:

Favourite player:

Best team moment:



carnyslop's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To carnyslop's Posts



To carnyslop's last 5 rumours posts


To carnyslop's last 5 talk posts


To carnyslop's last 5 rumour replies


carnyslop's rumours posts with other poster's replies to carnyslop's rumours posts


23 Feb 2018 17:29:46
Leivo and a 4th for kassian.




23 Feb 2018 17:27:17
Jvr, carrick liligran a first and 3rd for ek and ryan.




29 Jan 2015 17:33:54
Toronto needs a big change to start building for the future. They need a number one center to build around ,along with Reilly and bernier. The only team that can afford to trade a number one center is colarado, since they have two.
To col. Kessel franson and a 2nd
To tor. McKinnon, that leaves them with duch and orielly.


1.) Agree they need a number 1 center,

However as soon as they trade kessel they will be looking for a player exactly like him to play with the number 1 center.

If edm gets 1 of the top 2 picks they will be trading either (eichel/mcdavid) or RNH. They won't keep both and they can't because they need defenceive help.

Toronto should hold out and use nylander, gardiner, reimer, 1st 2015, phaneuf, even reilly or JVR to try and land one of edmontons centerman.

both teams need to do something big. McDavid a leaf!

2.) COL wouldn't do this trade. it makes no sense to trade MacKinnon right now, even if you're getting Kessel (which is really the only thing intriguing about what's been offered here). Maybe if it was TO 1st and a d-man with some term. and that's still a BIG maybe.

3.) 30 Jan 2015 19:15:44
Leafs pass. Mckinnon is a bust. Only one decent season



15 Nov 2014 03:41:45
To edm: reimer and robidas
To t.o : petty and a 3rd

Then to car: kadri Gardiner Ashton and a 2nd
To t.o e.stall


1.) No thnank you edmonton if you were the last team in the nhl i would not deal with you ,cause you always want to give away trash and want good players so no thankyou




carnyslop's talk posts with other poster's replies to carnyslop's talk posts


28 Nov 2014 17:56:38
I know there are a lot of leaf haters here, but that aside what ( being fair ) would Toronto have to give up to get Stewart from buffalo.
I was thinking Gardner who is young and a lot of upside


1.) Nothing. Their issues have little to do with their forward depth.

Trading Gardiner does (or anyone off the D right now - unless it's to bring back a D-man) not make sense.

2.) I was talking to a leaf fan at my school and he said Toronto has 2 of the best goalies in the league. He also said Bozak was the best center.

3.) 28 Nov 2014 21:45:41
A true Leaf fan, lol.

THEGR81 is correct, don't think TOR needs Stewart. Should rather go for D.

4.) Well your friend is mistaken. bernier and riemer have to be the best tandem in the world, not just the NHL and bozak is a lock for the HOF. hahah i'm sure he was joking buddy

5.) Pro depth your friend is an person and there is no way around it

There not the worst goalies but far from the best.
Not the worst first line c but very far from the top



16 Nov 2014 03:12:17
Toronto has hit a new low losing 6-2 to buffalo.without orr and McLaren they have become to soft, I like clarckson but when that's your toughest player your team is in trouble. The only reason Toronto made the playoffs and when to 7 games was their toughness and obviously skill , but without that toughness they wouldn't have made the playoffs. Playing without toughness and not getting a true number one center to play with kessel they might as well have a fire sale and start over. The other option is get rid of Noni's , and stop shanahan from trying to turn them into the redwings.


1.) 16 Nov 2014 07:58:32
yup ,lose one game need to rebuild and tear down. but next wekk say they win all 3 of their games its time to trade rielly, nylander and all firsts for the next 5 years for older upgrades cause obvioulsy TOR's a cup contender then.

2.) ^^^^ keep it up shankar!

3.) 16 Nov 2014 19:22:26
i don't like to insult people, but stuff like that just annoys me. sure, they lost to BUF and it was ahorrible game, but saying you have to rebuild because of it is just annoying.

4.) I guess Boston should probably rebuild too after losing to Toronto 6-1 and then Montreal 5-1.

Makes so much sense.

5.) @THEGR81 at least Boston hasn't lost 9-2.



15 Nov 2014 03:55:13
Tor edm trade not bad . I posted one similar reimer and robidas for petty and a 3rd




03 Jul 2014 02:09:57
Vrbata to the canucks




01 Jul 2014 13:38:55
Looks like gorges is a poor mans lindros.this is why I don't understand no trade clauses. All the people in farm clubs that would love to be up playing the sport they love and you get idiots like gorges pulling a lindros. Shame on him


1.) Answer me this. why would he want to go to Toronto?

2.) If he's willing to play in montreal, he should have no problem playing in toronto.

3.) Totally different situation ovie montreal has a winning team and he is already there. my point is why would he agree to go to Toronto when he has a choice. i'm sure there are at least 15 other teams who are more desirable now then the leafs.

4.) They answered this on tsn on insider trading I believe when they mentioned Gorges is somewhat old school where he does not want to play for his teams rival. I think that's more the reason for him not wanting to leave then say the media spotlight and such.

5.) I get what your saying, he doesn't have to leave or want to leave, but you're still a person for saying the leafs are a losing team or an undesirable destination, get your head out of the clouds champ, this seasons over we both lost. the habs are not cup contenders so them being a "winning" team doesn't say much to draw in big name players who want to win.

lebron would not be bringing his talents to montreal if he played puck

hey buds response seems legitimate

6.) You can't honestly think with the shape the leafs are in and how mad the media are there that players are jumping at the chance to go there. for god sakes man look what they had to pay for Clarkson and he was a home town boy. you my friend need to take your head out of the clouds and come back to reality

7.) @ Hab

Clarkson was going to get signed some where for at least 5-+6 million on a 5-6 year deal. I don't think he's a good example to use for the point you're making.

To your point, why would a player put a NTC into their contract if not for a scenario like This one. I get the point the poster is making, but why go somewhere you may be unhappy. However, I don't think it has nearly as much to do with the exposure one receives while in Toronto as you're suggesting.

In general, unless the trade was for a throw away piece from Toronto's end, I am glad they are not getting Gorges. He's a good player, but not one I would unload young talent for.

8.) Yeah because Buffalo is a better place to go to.

Never mind from a hockey side of the deal
Buffalo is a poor poor city
Bad winters poor everything

At least Toronto has a great mayor Rob FOrd. lol

DOnt hold that against us

9.) Hab

Gionta at 5 M was so much better

Where is he now

Oh yeah Buffalo

10.) Ok will maybe bolland is a better example

11.) Gionta?had it not been for a season where he missed 50 games and the lockout year he would have had 4 straight 20 plus goal seasons in montreal plus 18 more last year in a mainly defensive role. remind me what has clarkson done since coming to toronto? now I feel like he could have a bounce back year but right now he's one of if not the worst signings in the league. and yes gionta is in buffalo, montreal loses him at just the right time. how many more years does clarkson have?

12.) Eh hab! Your head is bigger than your whole team.

13.) I feel Georges on This, why would he be willing to be enemy number one enemy in Toronto when we know that they are big long therm rival! Were going to miss him! I do think The deal was bether in Toronto! let's be honnest the way that leaf d has been treated on the last few years ex: komisarek, gleason. I understand Georges not wanting to go there!




carnyslop's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

15 Oct 2018 16:10:09
Dont think willy will do a bridge deal or iw would be done by now. Its going to come down to trading him. So do it now and get that money helping our blue line.




Click To View This Thread

11 Oct 2018 19:18:41
If price is a stanley cup then why hasn't montreal won a cup with him.




Click To View This Thread

25 Sep 2018 20:40:34
Nylander will only go for an upgrade on defense.




Click To View This Thread

15 Sep 2018 05:45:34
Dubas sounded confident that he will sign the big three. Starting to wonder now. Maybe willie changed his mind i see no other reason. Willy should be signed by now there must be more to it.




Click To View This Thread

21 Aug 2018 20:16:07
If habs are looking to rebuild they can't use weber to do it. They would have to give a good piece just for someone to take his contract. They are stuck with him.





carnyslop has no Talk Replies