NHL Trade Rumors 36937

 

Use our rumours form to send us nhl trade rumors.

04 May 2015 21:05:05
Some potential Phaneuf trades:

To EDM:
Dion Phaneuf (retain $1.5m)

To TOR:
2015 1st Round Pick (Pittsburgh)
Nikita Nikitin (cap dump)
Marco Roy (B-level prospect)

Trade 2:

To DET:
Dion Phaneuf

To TOR:
Ryan Sproul (good defensive prospect)
Stephen Weiss (cap dump)
2016 2nd Round Pick

Thoughts?

Agree6 Disagree9

04 May 2015 21:47:32
cant see toronto retaining salary if they are going to also be taking on a cap dump on the first one. and I think they could get something better from detroit

04 May 2015 23:26:14
Detroit wants salary retained on a Phaneuf deal and would be willing to offer a little more than that to make it happen.

05 May 2015 00:45:26
Not saying Toronto would do it but Niktin is only signed for one more year I believe so it's not that bad of a camp dump

05 May 2015 01:04:59
In the Detroit trade, there isn't too much they have that they would be willing to give up for Phaneuf. I mean we can get older players but there isn't much point in that, they won't give us Mantha or Larkin so they could probably turn their 2nd round pick into a 1st but you can't get much more than that.

05 May 2015 02:18:51
As an Oiler fan and Phaunuf hater ill admit that's a good trade for him, retaining salary is key IF Oilers even want him, and that cap dump is only one more season, the 16th overall makes up for that. Actually decent compared to the other garbage proposal some want out of Edm.

05 May 2015 03:31:49
Add dallas, Philly and colarado to that list as well.

All cusp of playoff teams looking for a defenceman.

Asking price for phaneuf will be 1st round pick, top prospect and salary going back torontos way.

If its a Detroit proposal start with 1st, Mantha, and Weiss. Otherwise the leafs don't do the deal, Detroits prospects outside of mantha and larkin are not NHL caliber. The cupboards are bare.

05 May 2015 09:28:52
Finally something rather realistic. Pretty sure Roy isn't a B-Lvl-prospect. We had these discussions earlier on here, most people do not seem to know the definitions (neither did I, before sbr2017 posted them on here).

05 May 2015 11:21:39
Nikitin "cap dump" is for 1 season. Phanuef cap dump is for 7 seasons. And you want a top-20 draft pick and a prospect included as well?

This trade is absurd.

05 May 2015 12:29:01
Chirp, as an Oiler fan and a Phaneuf hater ill admit this is the most realistic proposal I've seen yet, Phaneuf isn't that crazy of a cap dump if they retain $1.5M a season. I still do not like the slightest idea of him in an Oilers jersey tho. Lol the reason the pick is a top 20 is because they would be retaining $1.5M. did you miss that part?

05 May 2015 13:35:49
Solid trades although I wouldn't mind a better prospect from Edmonton but would still happily take it from a leafs standpoint.

05 May 2015 14:22:03
I guess you forgot the part where Toronto retains $1.5 million of Phaneuf's salary. But why would you pay attention to detail?

06 May 2015 09:37:22
It's still too much and too long of a bad contract to take on.

06 May 2015 22:53:02
Maybe, But he would be EDM's best dman





 

 

 
Log In or Register to post

User
Pass
Remember me

Forgot Pass