Use our rumours form to send us nhl trade rumors.

02 Oct 2019 19:09:45
MTL: Hall

NJ: Peohling, Mete, Gallagher, plus 2 second round picks.

Agree3 Disagree21

02 Oct 2019 19:55:29
I think this deal is good

If jersey sees or gets the feeling they can't resign hall then this is a more than acceptable trade offer.

Maybe to sweetin the pot a bit offer a conditional 1st if hall resigns on the 2020 and a 2nd if he doesn't

Also put a condition on that if gallagher resigns with jersey, jersey owes montreal a 2nd in 2022

Still one heck of an offer. love to have gallagher on my team any day.

02 Oct 2019 20:27:19
3rd line center, top 4 d, 1st line rw, 2 2nds? Are you out of your mind?! No from Montreal

02 Oct 2019 20:51:56
All this for a ufa? don't think so.

03 Oct 2019 00:35:56
All this. And doesn’t fill the most pressing need. Actually takes away a left handed Defenseman. Value wise. I see the potential.

03 Oct 2019 01:37:02
If hall gets traded there's definitely a 1st involved.

03 Oct 2019 04:23:35
MTL would need to give up a lot in order to acquire a player of Hall's caliber and talent. When he's fully healthy, he's an 85-95 pt a season first liner. So, several pieces would likely need to be offered by Habs to entice NJ to seriously mull over an offer. Gallagher is the key component of this offer. Poehling, Mete and the 2 2nd rounders are all secondary components. Obviously, we can always tweak the offer by substraction and addition.

03 Oct 2019 06:03:26
Wgmj. But, there is several pieces in this proposal. The first 6/ 7 lines of your response made me 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️.

03 Oct 2019 15:25:47
This looks like a trade for someone who has a contract, not a UFA. I think it would be less if its a rental and more if he was under contract.
As for team needs, I don't think MTL would go for this.

03 Oct 2019 16:24:20
Its jus to much to give. Yes Hall is a great talent.
However, is one player worth all that? Some will say quality is worth more than quantity, which is true, but Gallagher is a quality player as well. Mete, is a young Dman only getting better all the time, and his absence would decimate an already weak side on Habs D. Poehling, I think has all the tools to be a solid top 6 . Most will say 3rd liner, until he plays regular in the NHL, I suppose the 3rd line argument wins. 2 2nds, could be another Gallagher or Subban ect. so I dunno. I'm not for sending 5, 6 peices for 1. K tear me apart now guys.

04 Oct 2019 15:57:40
Duchene got 2 first, a 3rd and a goalie. 1 of the 1st was drafted the year before but still a 1st. He was ufa. It's the price to pay.

04 Oct 2019 16:45:19
Way too much for a rental player as Hall is a UFA after this season. 2nd round pick and maybe one longshot prospect would be the rental rate for a UFA who's got the mindset already of bolting to the highest bidder this year. and Yes Hall will be bolting. Montreal offering up those players would need to get back someone with term on their contract.

Foolish move on Montreal's part to liquidate that much talent for 1 year worth of Hall's service.
Better idea to keep the talent and go get him next year as a UFA. but it's going to cost some bucks to get him.

04 Oct 2019 17:19:28
Shoot are you talking about the first trade or the second?

05 Oct 2019 02:08:21
This is the most lopsided trade proposal I’ve seen in months. And I only been on here a few weeks. Why anyone team makes this trade is unknown. Why would Montreal even consider this?



Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass