Use our rumours form to send us nhl trade rumors.

02 Jan 2021 02:24:31
To Calgary:
Pierre Luc Dubois

Sean Monahan
Oliver Kylington

Agree8 Disagree13

02 Jan 2021 04:24:58
I think that would be a no from Columbus.

02 Jan 2021 05:08:30
Monahan is a 30 goal scorer, Kylington is a 6th/7th defensemen, and a 1st? How does Calgary keep adding after Monahan? Columbus takes that in a heartbeat, Calgary declines hard.

02 Jan 2021 13:08:01
It's pretty simple, Dubois is younger, bigger, plays a more physical game, is better defensively and produces pretty well offensively too in spite of being on a defense first team with very little offensive talent to play with him.

In short, Dubois is already better and at his age probably hasn't peaked yet.

02 Jan 2021 16:37:42
Casual, in this case it would be age and contact situation that would make it a no, IMO. Not necessarily value.

02 Jan 2021 17:54:12
MoxNix said it perfectly. John Tortirella runs a very conservative system similar to the Islanders with Barry Trottz that doesn’t favour well with high point production. Monahan is very overrated imo he’s a 2c that can be a 1c with elite wingers.

03 Jan 2021 02:03:38
@Nylander I agree that he’s a 2C, 1C with Elite Wingers but he isn’t overrated at all. Monahan never gets talked about. None of Calgary really ever gets talked about unless it’s Tkachuk, Giordano (only because of Norris) Giordano was underrated for so many years before getting recognized for his Norris Caliber performance.

03 Jan 2021 05:47:58

Now I'm curious. If you think Monahan is a "2C, 1C with Elite Wingers", then why did you say Calgary declines hard to this trade proposal?

The 2 hardest things to acquire are a number 1 center and a number defenseman. Dubois would be an upgrade on Monahan and if he is available there'd be plenty of other teams interested. The main advantage Calgary would have over other teams is Monahan is probably a better center than most other teams would offer in return.

Not enough by himself. Kylington is a player a strong defensive team like Columbus could use to help with offense. The two of them still wouldn't be enough. If they don't add a first they'd probably have to add a good young roster player they don't want to give up, like Benny, Mangi, Dube.

03 Jan 2021 22:05:54
Cause I don’t think Luc Dubois is a #1 Center. Me and a lot of hockey pages on Instagram feel the same on that. He’s a solid 2C. Monahan has proved way more, I’ll take Monahan any day

04 Jan 2021 17:49:38
Lol there’s where you’re going wrong. Instagram is not a platform to gather information on hockey. That’s like me saying many people agree the bruins suck because a drunk guy at the bar said that while puking in the bathroom.



Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass