12 Dec 2023 20:57:52
Ott : Chabot, Taresenko, Jarventie, Forsberg/ Korpisalo, and a 2nd in 2024

Det : Seider, 3rd in 2026

Then

Ott : Batherson, Kubalik, Sokolov, and a 1st in 2024

Njd : L. Hughes, and a 2nd in 2026

Sanderson Seider
Chychrun Hughes
Branstrom Zub
Klevin.

1.) 12 Dec 2023
12 Dec 2023 22:11:13
I don’t like these trades from any side.

2.) 12 Dec 2023
12 Dec 2023 23:52:39
I don’t see this as any more likely than the McDavid/ Draisaitl trade you posted.

3.) 13 Dec 2023
13 Dec 2023 01:10:21
Here’s some fair trades-

Brady Tkachuk and 1st for Sieder (RHD>Wingers)

Stutzle for Luke Hughes

Nobody wants your garbage for their stars.

4.) 13 Dec 2023
13 Dec 2023 01:46:05
VbbVbb how are those anywhere close to fair for Ottawa? Feel your head.

That's like saying Edmonton trading McDavid and a 1st for Chabot and Draisaitl for Zub are fair. Get real dude. And these are both severe but necessary overpayments on Ottawas end.

Detroits gets a Lefty on the same tier as Seider but a few years older plus a starting Goalie, a Top 6 Forward, a pick, and a solid prospect who's tearing things up in ahl right now.

While New Jersey gets arguably the BEST current contract in hockey on a Top 6 Forward, a decent 25 goal scoring middle 6 guy, a decent prospect who ain't afraid to throw his body around and an unprotected 1st.

Not sure how these can be considered bad trades for Detroit or New Jersey? That just don't make any sense.

Seider is good but he ain't head and shoulders above someone like Chabot if he's even above him at all.

And Hughes is still in the proving stages of his career, NOT by any means on a top tier level yet.

5.) 13 Dec 2023
13 Dec 2023 12:06:40
Stevie Y and his scouts stole Seider in plain sight of all the other teams, and it has really worked out well. I don’t expect he’ll be trading him any time soon for these trades or any others, in my humble opinion.

6.) 13 Dec 2023
13 Dec 2023 14:13:43
You can make an argument that due to his physical play, superb defensive positioning and combination of offence that his top end physicality separates him for Makar, Dahlin, Hedman, Fox etc. you can argue that he’s the best defender in hockey. He’s the closest thing to a modern day Scott Stevens not I don’t think he’s the best but there is a argument there. I’d personally put him in line with Quinn Hughes and Charlie McAvoy with Sieder being far better player in his own end then Hughes.

Chabot isn’t even in discussions being a top 32 dman. He’s the 3rd dman on a non playoff senators behind Chychrun and Sanderson on top of that he’s injury prone. Value wise imo he’s in line with a player like Arron Eklblad.

Luke Hughes is the most promising young dman in the game and his impact is far greater then what his brother brought at this age. He is the much better defender then Quinn in his own end and in 2/ 3 years he will be the better player then Stutzle.

It’s hard to argue with someone who believes they’re right when the world dissagrees. There’s a reason why your “great sens” will miss the playoffs and it’s because your players aren’t as good as you think.

Also teams don’t just go move their star players on the whim. Detroit and New Jersey look like 2 very promising teams and won’t break up there roster.

7.) 13 Dec 2023
13 Dec 2023 23:14:33
Wow, not sure what's most absurd? The fact that you massively undercut what guys like Chabot and Chychrun have already done and what Sanderson is doing right now, or the fact you are putting guys like Seider and Hughes on such a pedistool they will never live up to?

Seriously take a good long read of what you have there. And you say I'm living in a delusion outside the rest of the world? Lmfao. There's a reason I haven't bothered making proposals for Makar. Unlike Seider and L. Hughes, he actually is head and shoulders above the rest. Saying Seider is better than him just proves my point, that you litteraly know absolutely nothing about hockey. That is laughable at best.

And Chabot NOT being Top 32? Lmfao on what planet? Lol not only is Chabot Top 32 so is Chychrun and Sanderson. Love to here the 32 you have above them? Lol might find 15, possibly even 20 better, not likely but possible, but not a chance in hell there's 32 above any of those 3 guys lol feel your head. I'll start your list for you to make it easier to find more and you still won't.

Makar
Fox
Heiskanen
Hedman
Josh
Carlson
Q. Hughes
Dahlin
MacAvoy
Hamilton

There's 10 to give you a head start Lol please name another 22 so the rest of the world can laugh at your failed efforts Lol

And no chance whatsoever that L. Hughes will be half as good as Stutzle will be. Bank on that!

8.) 14 Dec 2023
14 Dec 2023 14:23:07
As I said i personally don’t believe he is better then Makar but one could argue his 2 way play and physicality place him above Makar in terms of all around impact. Chabot is mediocre in his own end and hasn’t produced to his expectations offensively as I said he’s on par with Arron Eklblad and maybe a brandon Montour or Jacob Trouba.