09 Nov 2023 19:53:03
Lindholm 50%
Hanifin 50%

Geekie
Guenther
Lamareau
2024 2nd
2025 2nd


Coyotes believing it's time to go for it

10 Nov 2023 04:07:42
Imo they can get a way better return if they retained 50% on both Hanifin and Lindholm if they were to trade them separately.

10 Nov 2023 16:15:58
I don’t think both of those UFAs are worth Guenther alone. He’s looking like a superstar with 7 years of term control.

10 Nov 2023 17:11:45
Coyotes believing its time to go for it? what is "it"? . a new location? some fans? lol.

10 Nov 2023 18:05:43
VB you need to watch more hockey and lose the blinders, how many superstars get cut and end up in the ahl. Casual that equates to 3 first and 2 seconds, pretty good return.

11 Nov 2023 02:33:45
Nashan- Elias Petterson, Mitch Marner, William Nylander, Cale Makar, both Tkachuks, Quinn Hughes, Leon Drais, Etc tons of elite high 1st rd picks take time to make it to the NHL. Guenther will not be moved for any UFA including William Nylander ( leafs fan ) Guenther due to his term control absolutely has more value then Nylander even if it’s a sign and trade.

Some people like Nashan for an example don’t understand that not all 1st round picks have equal value for an example the 1st overall pick last year had far more value then the 32nd pick. 3 1sts from a team like Vegas for those 2 might be fair but a elite top 10 pick has the value of 3 1sts imo.

Guenther 9th overall and Geekie 11th overall will not be traded for 2 UFAs Or probably at all.

12 Nov 2023 00:51:54
I do understand what you mean about first round picks. I can give you many examples where a lower pick turns out better than a higher pick. Take Guenther for instance, I would take Johnston from Dallas on Guenther who cracked a much tougher roster than the Yotes have. Last point. To improve through trade comes at a cost other teams aren’t giving first line and top 4 D away.

13 Nov 2023 18:19:36
Obviously not all 1st round picks pan out I never said that but I am saying Guenther has been drafted recently and his value has not been lowered due to poor play. He absolutely has more value then those UFAs.

13 Nov 2023 21:24:26
For a team making a push for playoffs the ufa’s are more important than project players. Hence why teams give up draft capital and prospects for now improvement. Good convo thou, which I’ve found over some of these trade proposals. ????.