04 Aug 2022 04:03:47
Let's give this one a go, @MoxNix is wanting More Size & Grit

WAS's Anthony Mantha @5.7/UFA24 + Garnet Hathaway @1.5/UFA23 FOR
CGY's Tyler Toffoli @4.5/UFA24 + Oliver Kylington @2.5/UFA24 + Milan Lucic @50% Retained = $2.6125

WAS should have sufficient LTIR to take on the additional Cap Hit and need all 3 = Right Shot + Better D + 4LD Toughness CGY brings in a French RW for Huberdeau + a Big, Physical 3/4RW who can Score and Kill Penalties

04 Aug 2022 04:43:27
Cheaper option might be to sign Jake Virtanen to a PTO.

04 Aug 2022 15:25:36
Washington laughs at this.

04 Aug 2022 17:10:09
That's because you ridiculously think Toffoli's only worth a 2nd vbbb

Mantha 20-22: 24G+28A=52PTS/ 93GP = 0.56PPG
Toffoli 20-22: 48G+45A=93PTS/ 126GP = 0.74PPG

CGY would be Crazy to do this Trade. Not only is Toffoli Better, Mantha hasn't ever been able to play a Full Season. I like Hathaway, but he's a Rental.

05 Aug 2022 01:41:33
Calgary should have resigned Hathaway in the first place instead of letting Washington sign him.

05 Aug 2022 02:55:23
Mantha was battling injuries that’s not fair. He also is a great 2way player. Nobody wants Toffoli him and Kerfoot have equally little value as the market is small.

05 Aug 2022 05:09:28
Yeahhhhhh, I’m gonna have to go ahead and just disagree with you there @vbbbvvbb

Toffoli, Kerfoot, Holl, Kylington, Valimaki, N. Robertson, Ruzicka are all gonna surprise you over the next couple seasons My Friend

Go ahead and please get those TPS Reports to me when you can, mmmmmkayy!?

05 Aug 2022 17:06:49
@TrevorA I'm going to disagree with you in regards to Holl. I think we've seen him at his peak. I'm hopeful Robertson gets a legitimate chance on that second line. Not a few games or a few shifts. Give him a month to figure it out and some time on the 2nd PP and I think he could put up 60 points.

05 Aug 2022 19:15:52
I Appreciate You Anyways @MG69!

Holl definitely gives the puck away and makes costly mistakes from time to time, but for $2mil, you'd be hard pressed to find a Better RD who can do it all. He's consistent & reliable, but you could always Trade him for a Bottom-6 Player like Tyson Jost or for a 3rd Round Pick to sign PK Subban instead.